Expanded marine anoxia at the Cambrian-Ordovician transition: Evidence from lime mudstone I/Ca and δ238U signatures of the GSSP in western Newfoundland, Canada

The early Paleozoic witnessed two spectacular radiations of marine organisms—the Cambrian (Є) Explosion and the Great Ordovician (O) Biodiversification Event. However, the period between them was characterized by a marine biodiversity plateau attributed to recurring biocrises. In the current study, we present the I/Ca records from slope lime mudstones of the Green Point Formation in western Newfoundland, along with a three-sink U-isotope mass balance model and previously reported limestone δ238Ucarb signals of the same interval, to further explore oceanic redox conditions at the Є-O boundary. The I/Ca ratios of the lime mudstones, deposited along the eastern Laurentian (western Iapetan) continental slope, exhibit a narrow range between 0.02 and 0.33 μmol/mol. Poor correlations between the I/Ca values and their [Sr], δ18O, Mn/Sr, Fe/Sr, Mg/Ca, and δ13Corg counterparts, together with near-micritic textures of the limestones, argue against significant influences of postdepositional alterations on the I/Ca signatures. The iodine-depleted lime mudstones, with I/Ca values well below the Proterozoic Eon baseline I/Ca ratios (∼0.5–1 μmol/mol), suggest the presence of shallow marine oxic-anoxic interfaces along the regional continental margin. Substantially low limestone I/Ca ratios (<0.5 μmol/mol) and dysoxic to anoxic depositional conditions have also been reported from several other age-equivalent sections deposited along the shelf and slope of ancient Iapetan and Laurentian continental margins. As a result, seawaters surrounding the Iapetan and Laurentian continental margins at the Є-O transition might have been commonly poorly oxygenated with shallow oxyclines or expanded oxygen minimum zones in the shelf and/or slope areas. This interpretation is further supported by our three-sink U-isotope mass balance modeling, which predicts widespread marine anoxia at the Є-O boundary with anoxic to euxinic water covering 1.0–21.1% of the ocean floor, significantly higher than the modern day (∼0.2%). Furthermore, the wide range of the oceanic δ238UOC (−1.22 to −0.25‰) values, estimated from the limestone δ238Ucarb signals, might reflect oceanic redox oscillations during this period. However, the δ238UOC fluctuations could also be attributed to variable accumulations of the 238U-enriched authigenic U phases during early diagenesis. Overall, evidence from the lime mudstone I/Ca ratios and the estimated extent of marine anoxia at the Є-O boundary in this study aligns with earlier viewpoints that the slowness of marine biodiversity accumulation during the late Cambrian and the Early Ordovician was linked to widespread oceanic anoxia.